clhollandwriter: (Default)
In the wonderful Good Omens, there's a scene that muses on how many angels can dance on the head of a pin. The answer being one, because angels don't dance except for that one time Aziraphale learned the gavotte only to be disappointed when it went out of fashion.

Which then got me thinking about how writing is exactly like an angel learning to gavotte.

While it appears a throwaway reference in the book, the scene in the series has around thirty seconds of Aziraphale dancing. Not only did they have to find someone who knew how to gavotte to teach Michael Sheen and the dancers how to gavotte, they had to source appropriate music and costumes for the scene. They had to rehearse to make it look effortless. All for thirty seconds of film.

None of that research or practice is visible on the screen, and if writing is done well none of it's visible on the page either.

It's also not a throwaway reference at all. It refers to an argument in logical thinking first recorded as early as the seventeenth century, and probably even older, which is still in modern usage. In addition, the narrator (God in the TV adaptation) tells us that "Aziraphale had learned to gavotte in a discreet gentlemen’s club in Portland Place in the late 1880’s". That discreet club was probably The Hundred Guineas Club, an exclusive gay club, given the other gentlemen's club in Portland Place at the time was a gambling club and probably not the sort of place an angel would learn to dance. It also ties nicely in with other references in the text to people assuming Aziraphale's gay.

Which is to say, good writing has layers.

And finally, fashions come and go. If you spend all your time writing to market (or learning to gavotte) you're likely to be disappointed when the trends change. Write what you love, and enjoy yourself as much as Aziraphale clearly does in this (slightly edited) video of him dancing the gavotte.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
"Never hand someone a gun unless you're sure where they'll point it." - Commander Jeffrey Sinclair

As promised last week, this episode sees Commander Sinclair once again creatively interpreting rules and regulations to get the outcome he wants - in not one but both of the plot strands.

The plots are linked in that the same disaster causes both, that disaster happening only because of the plots' background happening in the same place at the same time in the first place. Confused yet? Fortunately it's pretty simple after it all kicks off. Faulty equipment leads to an accident in the docking bay which kills two dock workers, and a Narn ship is destroyed in the accident because the captain panics. Plot A is the dock workers going on strike because of the poor conditions that caused the accident, and the Narn ship is only there to deliver a sacred plant to Ambassador G'Kar for Plot B. Remove the poor working conditions or the Narn ship and there's no inciting incident. It's a clever piece of writing, that makes the threads feel unified even though they each go their separate ways from here.

Under the terms of their contract striking is illegal, and Sinclair tries to talk the dockers out of it before word can get back to Earth. However the government's new budget for Babylon 5 is leaked - and the dockers get nothing. They go on unofficial strike, all calling in sick, and Earth sends their best negotiator Orin Zento to step in. Sentator Hidoshi tells Sinclair "He has stopped this kind of thing before in other stations", succinctly letting the audience know that this is a widespread problem.

Unfortunately, Zento's skill as a negotiator appears to have nothing to do with negotiating and everything to do with talking loudly at people and threatening to invoke the Rush Act and have them arrested. Sinclair tries to persuade him to take a softer approach but then, not convinced they'll get the people and funding they need, the workers make the strike official. Zento invokes the Rush Act which has lead to arrests, rioting, and deaths on Europa and Matewan. As Garibaldi takes his security forces in, Sinclair tries and fails to get the senate to revoke their order. As a last resort he pulls a copy of the full text to find out exactly what it empowers him to do.

While this is going on, G'Kar's dealing with the repercussions of the destruction of the Narn ship, which was carrying a sacred G'Quan Eth plant which he needs for a religious observance. The only other plant on the ship is owned by Ambassador Mollari. Knowing full well Mollari won't give him the plant G'Kar breaks into his quarters and finds, knowing full well G'Kar will break in, Londo's hidden the plant elsewhere. He offers to sell it for an extortionate price although he'll be sad to lose it. In a nice touch of background (and putting a gun firmly in a drawer for later use) he states: "When you drop the seeds into a proper mixture of alcohol whole new universes open up. It's a shame you Narns waste them, burning them as incense!"

Of course when the time comes, having humiliated G'Kar, he refuses to sell.

Although he hates to do it G'Kar takes his grievance to Commander Sinclair, who's somewhat distracted by the strike and says he can't do anything as Mollari owns the plant. It's only at this point G'Kar dispatches Na'Toth to steal a statue of a Centauri deity (it's not specified which one) from the Centauri Cultural Centre. It's an interesting insight into his moral character that despite hating the Centauri an affront to their religious beliefs is his weapon of last resort and that, proud as he is, he's willing to humble himself by asking for help first. This episode, and the events of Mind War, show him to be much more spiritual than he generally lets on, and lays the groundwork for things that happen much, much later.

Things become violent between Garibaldi's men and the dockers, and Sinclair withdraws the security forces to meet the dockers face to face, with Orin Zento at his side. He asks Zento for confirmation that the Rush Act means he's empowered to end the strike by any means necessary, which Zento confirms. But the thing is, while those means are generally interpreted to mean military action and arrests, that's not what it actually says. Sinclair can do what he likes, so what he does is reallocate some of the increased military budget to repair the equipment and hire new workers. Zento isn't happy with it, but the dockers are and the strike ends.

Next stop is to see Ambassadors Mollari and G'Kar, who are about ready to kill each other. Once again using rules and regulations to solve his troubles, he tells Mollari that he's discovered the G'Quan Eth is a controlled substance which can only be owned for medical or religious purposes. This may or may not be true, since Mollari protests it's no worse than whiskey and Sinclair tells him to file a protest, but it allows him to confiscate the plant and give it to G'Kar on the condition the Centauri statue is returned.

The only problem is, it's too late to perform the ceremony. It must be carried out in the first rays of the sun to shine past the Q'Guan mountain on a particular day, those not on Narn must do it at the same time which has already passed. Sinclair has an answer for this too: "The sunlight that touched the mountain 10 years ago will reach this station in 12 hours. It's been on a long journey, but it's still the same sunlight". G'Kar agrees that this is enough, "You are a far more spiritual man than I gave you credit for", and the episode ends with him performing the ritual for a group of his people.

The docker plot doesn't end quite so peacefully. Senator Hidoshi calls Sinclair with a warning: his creative interpretation of the Rush Act has made him new enemies. His response? "So, what else is new?" He's already made an enemy of Bester in Mind War, within the senate in Deathwalker, and there's also the shadowy group behind the events of And the Sky Full of Stars. He does what he does to protect the station and its people, and in that respect his politicking is no different that ramming a Minbari cruiser or trying to take out the soul hunter. Garibaldi complains in Infection that Sinclair's always putting himself "on the line". He's just not always doing it by chasing monsters.

clhollandwriter: (Default)
"We are alike, you and I. We are both, as you say the odd man out. I have been in your place. I can feel how you are pinned. And it would give me some small pleasure to know that things can work out, even for us." - Londo Mollari

This episode brings us back round to Earth politics, and we get Garibaldi's backstory, both neatly tied up in a bow. It's fairly straightforward with an episode's worth of A plot and no B plot, and most of what it achieves is setting up groundwork for the season finale.

The fraught nature of things back on Earth is mentioned in the opening shots of a news channel reporting on President Santiago's upcoming visit to the station, which many people think is to build support for trade and immigration agreements with the alien races. He's bringing with him an escort of Cobra fighters that will be permanently based on Babylon 5, and while inspecting the bay they'll be housed in Garibaldi and Ivanova narrowly miss being caught in an explosion that kills a man and injures another.

The chief of presidential security, Major Lianna Kemmer, takes over the investigation. Unfortunately she has a personal issue with Garibaldi, and after she sidelines him and takes over the investigation Garibaldi loses his temper at a petty thief he catches for the third time that month. Sinclair takes him aside and demands an explanation. "I need a drink," Garibaldi replies, and orders water, making it pretty obvious the way his explanation is going to head. Given their long history, it hard to believe Sinclair doesn't already know himself.

Seventeen years previously, Garibaldi had been the only clean cop in the Europa ice-mining operation. The stress of trying to uphold the law when no one else cared made him hit the bottle pretty hard. His only other comfort was the time spent with the family of his friend Frank Kemmer - the Major's father - and they kept him "sane and sober". Then Garibaldi's work started to pay off, and in retaliation his enemies rigged a shuttle pad to explode as Frank ended his run. Garibaldi was framed for negligence, blackballed, and hit the bottle again.

Kemmer decides to interrogate Nolan, the survivor of the accident, even though doing so will kill him. When his response is "bomb" and Garibaldi's name she's more than happy to assume Garibaldi is guilty of sabotage. She has his quarters searched and her second in command Cutter finds Centauri ducats and schematics of the Cobra bay, clear proof of Garibaldi's guilt. She's not prepared to look any deeper, especially with traces of explosives found in the bay. Sinclair accuses her of a personal vendetta, and Garibaldi goes on the run.

Sinclair tries to buy time to find Garibaldi first by cancelling Kemmer's station-wide alert, knowing it will take time for her to contact Earth to have him overruled. Ivanova assists by ordering maintenance on the communications channels that will tie them up for several hours. Kemmer gets round it by using the comms channel on her ship, but it's enough to give Garibaldi a headstart.

He goes to see Ambassador Mollari, a sensible place to start given the Centauri ducats but Londo knows nothing about the plot. He suggests the Narn are responsible, having extorted ducats from the Cetauri in exchange for the scientific data they took during the occupation of Ragesh 3 in the first episode. Londo loans Garibaldi some money to get him by, stating he feels some measure of sympathy - but if Garibaldi's caught, he'll deny speaking to him. The next stop is Ambassador G'Kar, who denies his people are involved and invites Garibaldi to defect. Both of these encounters serve mainly to add characterisation to the parties involved. Londo is, as always, a hopeless romantic in rooting for the underdog, G'Kar is sneakily political and pragmatic, and Garibaldi himself states he'd rather die than take up G'Kar's offer.

Garibaldi's next stop is to try the station's criminal underworld, where he's refused service and then attacked. Sinclair tracks him down and saves him from a beating, once again proving to be a hands-on sort of commander, and tries to persuade him to come in. Garibaldi refuses and escapes while Sinclair's distracted. He insists on finding out who framed him, but instead finds a bar where he ends up at the bottom of a bottle.

Sinclair takes a call from General Netter ordering him to give Kemmer his full co-operation. He obeys, but accuses her again of having a personal vendetta. At this point they find out Garibaldi's been spending Londo's Centauri ducats, which only serves to make him look more guilty. Shortly after this he's brought in, drunk. Kemmer takes him to her command centre, while Cutter checks the bays again ahead of the president's arrival.

By this point in the season it's clear that Sinclair will try to get what he needs within the limitations set by his rank and the diplomatic demands of his position. In this case he gets Welch, Garibaldi's second, to search the quarters of Nolan. He finds detonators and pamphlets linked to right-wing group Home Guard who were behind the events of The War Prayer. Nolan's bomb had detonated early by accident.

It's a pretty straight run to the finish from there. They realise Home Guard are behind the plot, and that Cutter planted the evidence in Garibaldi's quarters while searching them. He also rigged the doors of the fighter bays to explode on opening, which is aborted with the time-honoured one second to spare. The president's life is saved and when he gives his address he invites the alien governments to work with Earth. The episode ends with Garibaldi and Kemmer reconciling. They promise to keep in touch, but like so many incidental characters we never hear from her again and it's likely she doesn't make it past the end of the season.

This isn't the last time we'll see personal vendettas running the plot - or even the last time this season. It's also not the first or last time Sinclair uses his interpretation of the rules and regulations to protect the station and its people. He's going to do it again in the very next episode, in fact.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
 "The avalanche has already started. It is too late for the pebbles to vote." - Ambassador Kosh

Full disclosure: I hate this episode. I think its attempt to tug the heartstrings is trite and obvious, and the entire confict that drives it makes no sense.

That said, let's take a closer look at how its put together.

The main plot of this episode hinges on the age-old theme of Man versus God, or in this case Doctor Franklin versus a religion that won't let him save a child's life. The boy Shon has a blockage in his upper air passages, something that Doctor Franklin tells his parents is common in species with internal air bladders. This a clumsy "as you know, Bob" moment, given the parents presumably already know this being of the same species themselves, but does serve to make Franklin look condescending and Doctor-knows-best so I suppose it fits in the context of this episode - if not with his wider characterisation.

Unfortunately the mass in Shon's airways has hardened and requires surgery to remove. Shon's parents protest - "the Chosen of God may not be punctured" - and that's where this whole episode falls down for me. Setting aside that it's a swipe at real-world religions that don't allow medical interventions, and anyone's opinion of that, it makes no sense in the context of the religion in the episode. The parents explain that cutting open is only done to food animals, since they have no soul which can escape. People have souls, which can escape, so what's left after surgery is a soulless demon. There are hints at the reasoning behind it - late in the episode it's revealed their species is egg-bearing, they call themselves Children of the Egg, and Shon's father insults Franklin by referring to him as the descendant of "egg-sucking mammals". Clearly eggs are important: puncture the shell and you lose what's inside.

This doesn't work for me for a couple of reasons. The first is the reference to the Chosen of God in the very first scene. "Children of the Egg may not be punctured" would have set up the foundation of their beliefs right at the start. Instead it sets it up as being much like an Abrahamic religion (Judaism, Christianity, Islam), an effect only added to by Shon's father's insistence he read the "Parable of the Seventh Declination in the Scroll of Herrell" rather than watching the station's entertainment channels. It doesn't help that early in the episode Shon's father also refers to them as Children of Time. The egg stuff isn't introduced until comparatively late in the episode, by which point all it does is make a confused mess of their belief system.

The rest of this plot goes about how you'd expect. Franklin goes to Commander Sinclair to override the parents' rights; the parents go to all the ambassadors, not having one of their own, and ask them to intervene. G'Kar refuses because it doesn't benefit the Narn to help them, Londo because they can't afford it, Delenn because the Minbari are forbidden to interfere in matters of the souls of others, and Kosh for the reason given at the top of the post. It is a nice touch that their response to Delenn is an incredulous "You are refusing because of your beliefs?" Sinclair agrees to make a ruling, but it doesn't go the way Franklin expects. After speaking to Shon's parents, and Shon himself, and getting absolutely no help from Earth's government, he decides the neutrality of Babylon 5 must come first, and that this means the parents' beliefs must be respected. Anyone coming to this having watched the pilot will know this is the exact opposite decision to the one he makes there, in ordering the doctor to operate to save Kosh's life. Franklin mentions this and is told "it has to stop somewhere".

Of course, Franklin does the operation anyway. Shon's parents are mortified and violently reject him, leaving him sobbing and alone. Later they return. His mother tells Franklin they know he only did what he thought was best for their son, and that if they were allowed to forgive him they would. Now they will take Shon, and they have brought his lamuda, a travelling robe for great journeys. Franklin assumes they meant to take Shon home and lets them go.

It's only at this point Franklin bothers to find out any background to their religion, and discovers the lamuda is used for spiritual journeys. He goes after them, but Shon is already dead.

The B plot is barely memorable: Ivanova's going stir-crazy and persuades Sinclair to let her lead a squadron of fighters to rescue a stranded civilian transport. Following a scout, without back-up and against regulations, she discovers and neutralises an ambush and everyone is saved. It doesn't do much but reinforce Ivanova's hot-headedness, and add a counterpoint that sometimes if you go against the rules it does work out.

Having looked at it in more detail, I think my main problem with this episode is its heavy-handedness. The religion plot could have worked, had the egg-based beliefs been front-loaded instead of tacked on like an afterthought, and a little more care taken to distance it from existing religions. Instead it's a mess and the whole episode suffers for it. In that I suppose it serves as a useful lesson in worldbuilding, if nothing else.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
"Understanding is a three-edged sword." - Ambassador Kosh.

This episode manages to be a standalone monster of the week episode, while simultaneously digging deep into themes that play into the wider arc. There's also a completely baffling encounter, that only makes sense if you look at this episode in terms of the overarching plot and the show's need to be flexible about external factors.

We open with Ambassador Kosh contracting telepath Talia Winters for a job, and Ambassador G'Kar's aide Na'Toth trying to kill a visitor to the station with her bare hands.

The visitor is a trader going by the name of Gyla Lobos, travelling with Minbari ID, clothes, and ship, although she's not Minbari. According to Na'Toth the visitor is Deathwalker, a Dilgar war criminal notorious for her experiments on prisoners - including Na'Toth's grandfather. The problem is, the Dilgar have been extinct for thirty years and Deathwalker herself should be much older.

G'Kar persuades Sinclair to release Na'Toth into house arrest in his custody, where she tells him she's sworn a blood oath to kill Deathwalker. She's not pleased when he tells her to put it aside for the good of their people - the Narn government is trying to make a deal with Deathwalker for a discovery that will give them an advantage over their enemies. Na'Toth agrees to postpone her claim and G'Kar promises to help her fulfill the blood oath once they have what they want. However Deathwalker's price is Na'Toth's execution and G'Kar refuses, despite his previous words to Na'Toth about the need to sacrifice for the greater good. It's a lovely piece of characterisation that even G'Kar, previously depicted as ruthless, has a line he won't cross.

The Narn aren't the only ones interested in Deathwalker's secrets. Sinclair receives a call from Senator Hidoshi back on Earth instructing him to send Deathwalker once she's recovered, and Ambassador Mollari stops Sinclair in the corridor to ask if the rumour of Deathwalker being in custody is true. The rumours spread even further once G'Kar warns the other ambassadors Deathwalker is on the station, to prevent her from leaving.

Deathwalker reveals to Sinclair that she is who Na'Toth claims. The reason she looks young is an anti-aging-and-disease serum she's developed, which she intends to share with the whole galaxy - immortality for all. She claims to have been sheltered by a Minbari faction called the Wind Swords, and comments they're right to fear Sinclair. This, of course, is a nod to the previous episode and the revelation that during the Earth-Minbari War he was captured and interrogated by the Minbari shortly before they surrendered, before being released with no memory of the encounter. It's also interesting that literally the only interaction Sinclair and Deathwalker have had at this point is Sinclair walking into Medlab, introducing himself, and asking Doctor Franklin to give them a moment. "You know the way of command" she tells him approvingly, but it's honestly difficult to imagine her phrasing her orders as questions. Her impression appears to be based on the fact Sinclair does exactly that, with the expectation of being obeyed, and Franklin does as he's told. There's very little of Franklin in this episode, but there's a lovely piece of characterisation here even though he doesn't say a word. When Sinclair arrives, Franklin is between Deathwalker and the door, clearly unhappy about being near her and just as clearly positioned to stop her leaving even though they both know he couldn't actually stop her.

As Sinclair prepares to ship Deathwalker off to Earth, the Ambassadors gang up on him and force a council meeting to decide what will be done with her - the League of Non-Aligned Worlds wants her to stand trial on Babylon 5. The problem is, they only get one vote between them. Sinclair votes with them (almost certainly not what Senator Hidoshi had in mind). The Vorlons, as always, abstain. The Centauri vote no and the Narn, after the trial being on Narn is refused, also vote no. Sinclair's plan hinged on the Minbari voting yes, but they don't. It's another nice characterisation note that it's Lennier who casts the vote as Delenn is away. He's obviously unhappy about doing it, but does as he's told and apologies to Sinclair after. He's also the one who admits the Wind Swords did harbour Deathwalker, and used her to create weapons to fight Earth with during the war, which the Minbari are now too ashamed to admit. It's almost certain Delenn would not have told Sinclair this, but Lennier doesn't appear to think twice and I'm not sure if this says more about him or his perception of Sinclair.

Vote defeated, they stick Deathwalker on a ship. This time a whole fleet of ships from the various League worlds arrives and threatens to attack the station. After a brief standoff, Sinclair tells the League ambassadors about the serum and proposes they send scientists to Earth to help with its development . When it's finished, they can have Deathwalker for trial - a more civilised version of what G'Kar promised Na'Toth. Deathwalker is scornful of the idea, saying the Earth Alliance won't let it stand. Her parting blow is to tell Sinclair that the key ingredient in her serum can't be made, it has to be harvested from other living beings. Watching the other races tear each other apart will be her legacy.

Then her ship leaves and the Vorlons blow it up.

Ambassador Kosh tells the rest they aren't ready for immortality, and glides away. While all this is going on Talia's having a very odd encounter, and really the only thing that connects the two storylines is that Kosh is in both.

It's established earlier in the season that Talia's job as a commercial telepath is to scan both parties during negotiations to ensure everyone's on the same page. Which is exactly what she does here, except that Kosh's associate Abbut has a completely blank mind, and the pair of them talk rubbish. Talia's confused and upset, since the constant scans are tiring and end in her having unpleasant flashbacks. The nonsense talk is amusing and adds some levity, but the whole thing would probably be a lot more interesting if it wasn't for all the Deathwalker business going on. However, since the whole point is to put a gun in a drawer that's never used (more on that later), burying it in a plot that's more interesting was probably the best thing they could have done with it.

At the end of the negotiations, Abbut removes his hat to reveal a cybernetic brain and removes a data crystal which he hands to Kosh. When asked, Kosh tells Talia it contains "Reflection, surprise, terror. For the future." Talia takes her concerns to Sinclair and Garibaldi, and the latter tells her Abbut is a Vicker (VCR, an excellent pun that only works if you believe people will still know what that is in the 23rd century), part organic and part machine, used by aliens to record things. They can only guess why Kosh wanted to record Talia, but their guess is that it's because Vorlons don't trust telepaths. What might be the real reason becomes apparent later.

Despite not actually moving on the main arc, the episode manages to touch on the themes of immortality, whole races going extinct, the need to sacrifice for the greater good, and Sinclair's backstory with the Minbari. Because of this, unlike other less successful monster of the week episodes, it's difficult to see how this one could be removed and not leave a gaping hole.

clhollandwriter: (Default)
"Everyone lies, Michael. The innocent lie because they don't want to be blamed. The guilty lie because they don't have a choice. Find out why he's lying, the rest will take care of itself." - Jeffrey Sinclair

This is the first episode that deals heavily with Sinclair's backstory and, it will later turn out, the main plot, and it's a weird one.

It all starts out fairly straightforward, with Sinclair and Garibaldi questioning one of the security personnel, Bensen, about his gambling habits. They believe he's been placing bets over the limits imposed on station staff and, although Bensen denies it, they're right. In order to settle his debts he supplies a power cell to a couple of shady characters.

In the meantime, Doctor Franklin is examining Ambassador Delenn to gather data on healthy Minbari. Since he usually sees them when they're sick, it will provide him with a baseline to work from. They chat about his past hitchhiking on starships and working for his passage, and that during the Earth-Minbari war he destroyed his xenobiology notes rather than have them used for biological warfare. Delenn is surprised and grateful, and dodges his question as to what she did during the war.

That night, Sinclair wakes up after a nightmare of the Battle of the Line. He finds his comms not working, and in one of the series more unsettling scenes he makes his way to C&C to find it - and the whole station - deserted. All except for one other person. His unnamed captor tells him they're inside Sinclair's mind, in a virtual reality constructed to get to the bottom of what exactly happened during Sinclair's missing 24 hours during the battle - at the end of which the Minbari surrendered. Sinclair's report stated his ship was damaged, he tried to ram a Minbari cruiser and blacked out, but there are a number of people back home who don't believe him. They think he betrayed Earth, agreed to be a spy for the Minbari, and that the increasing alien presence and influence back on Earth is evidence of this.

The interloper tries a number of tricks to get Sinclair to cooperate. He summons and kills an image of Garibaldi, inflicts pain on Sinclair, and conjures shades of a dead comrade who accuses him of betrayal. Sinclair, realising that time is limited and people will be looking for him, fights back and hurts his captor, forcing him out of the simulation.

While all this could be happening at the speed of thought, it actually takes long enough that Chief Garibaldi reports Sinclair missing - he's an hour late for a meeting and no one's seen him since the previous evening. He starts a full scale search of the station, even outside in case they're looking for a body. The body they find is Bensen, who interrupted the interrogation of Sinclair and is killed for it. The search's proximity to where Sinclair's being held makes his kidnappers panic and they ramp up the psychotropic drugs in the hope it will make him snap.

It does, but not in the way they expect.

Sinclair remembers the Minbari assassin in the pilot telling him "there's a hole in your mind". He remembers ramming the cruiser, being taken on board and inspected by the Grey Council who wave a glowing device at him. He remembers seeing Delenn there. The shock of it ejects him from the virtual reality where, believing himself in hostile territory, he smashes the simulator. He then tries to kill Garibaldi, who's just found him. Hallucinating and frightened, he goes on on the run.

What follows is a three way chase with the second captor chasing Sinclair, Garibaldi's forces chasing them both, and Sinclair unable to tell friend from foe. He's stopped by Delenn, who puts herself in the line of fire to talk him down. He comes out of it enough to shoot the second captor before collapsing and being taken to medlab.

The plot here is a fairly simple one, the main story being Sinclair's experiences and the B plot the search for him. But the episode overall does some pretty hard work in terms of characterisation and story arc. As well as finding out more about Doctor Franklin, it also reveals more about Sinclair. The mental construct is of Babylon 5, and that's where he comes back to when resisting his captor, who accuses him of hiding behind duty and responsibility. We see a triluminary for the first time, although we're not told what it is or what the Grey Council are using it for. It's also revealed that the growing xenophobia back on Earth is deeply rooted, possibly even within the government.

At the end of the episode, Sinclair goes to see Delenn to thank her for her help. He tells her "strange that seeing you snapped me out of it" and it's a nice touch that it's not clear which time he means. She asks if he remembers anything of his experience - another ambiguous phrasing, since it's not clear here either which encounter she's referring to. Sinclair lies and tells her no, although it's suggested Delenn suspects he's lying simply in the way she reacts. After he's gone another member of the Grey Council warns her that should he remember, Sinclair must be killed. In his quarters, Sinclair admits in his log he remembers. His goal now is to find out what the Minbari wanted with him ten years ago.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
"Something my father said. He was…old, very old at the time. I went into his room, and he was sitting, alone in the dark, crying. So I asked him what was wrong, and he said, "My shoes are too tight. But it doesn't matter, because I have forgotten how to dance." I never understood what that meant until now. My shoes are too tight, and I have forgotten how to dance." - Londo Mollari

This is one of my favourite episodes in terms of the writing, because the three plots are linked and work well together (unlike the disaster to come that is TKO).
 
A close friend of Ambassador Delenn's, Minbari poet Shaal Mayan, is visiting the station. On her way back from Delenn's quarters she's attacked by an Earth-First hate group, who leave her stabbed and branded. This isn't the first attack, and although Commander Sinclair puts security chief Garibaldi on it, it's not enough for Ambassador G'Kar who starts agitating the alien population to fight back. This always strikes me as out of character for G'Kar, making a public spectacle being more Ambassador Mollari's sort of thing. While the show hasn't yet revealed anything about his past as a freedom fighter, he's been shown to be a private person who deals with problems behind the scenes - as he did when there was a price on his head. Inciting to riot doesn't seem like his style.

In the meantime, a pair of Centauri runaways arrive on the station, Kiron and Aria, who've been betrothed to other people but want to marry each other. They end up in Mollari's custody, in part because Kiron is his aide Vir's cousin. Mollari is less than sympathetic - marrying for love is just not done in Centauri society. He himself has three wives, who he refers to as pestilence, famine, and death (fittingly placing himself as war) although none of them are on the station with him. He books Kiron and Aria passage home and washes his hands of the matter.
 
Ivanova also receives a visitor, an old boyfriend Malcolm Biggs. For a while it looks like he wants to rekindle their relationship, but it soon turns out he has other motives. When Kiron and Aria are hospitalised by the same group that attacked Mayan, there are retaliatory attacks on humans - one a known xenophobe who was questioned about the previous attack. Biggs is caught on camera trying to recruit him into the Home Guard, an Earth-first terrorist faction.
 
Sinclair engages in skullduggery. He recruits Ivanova to plant some seeds about how he's unhappy with aliens on Earth himself, and introduce them. Sinclair's rude to the ambassadors at a reception, and in short order is telling Biggs how he "really" feels. Biggs takes the bait and is arrested along with his accomplices who attacked Maya, Kiron, and Aria.

Not only do the plots tie together well, but there's some nice characterisation. We hear from Biggs how Ivanova always put her career and duty before her personal life, and then we see it in action - firstly when she cuts her conversations with him short because of problems on the station, and later when she agrees to help Sinclair take him down. There's more of the Minbari as a deeply spiritual people, shown in Delenn's relationship with Mayan and Mayan's reaction to being attacked, and this in turn influences how Mollari decides to deal with his young runaways.

Mayan tells him he should allow Aria to sit in Medlab with Kiron while he's unconscious, because love is a potent healing force. Mollari, with his three unloved and unloving wives, is initially scathing - young people should learn to live without love. "As you did?" she asks him. It's only been a few episodes since Mollari was revealed to be a romantic himself, and a large chunk of future plot hinges on his inability to live without the one he loves. In the end, he arranges for Kiron and Aria to be fostered by his second cousin, which will bring honour to their own families, and when they're old enough will be allowed to choose for themselves who to marry.

There's also a tiny bit of the main story arc, with just enough Ambassador Kosh to be funny without his deliberate vagueness becoming annoying. Garibaldi and Sinclair muse about the nature of Vorlons, and remind the audience of the events of the pilot- of how Kosh was poisoned despite being in his encounter suit, and how the doctor and telepath who were the only people to respectively see and scan a Vorlon were shipped back home shortly after. This is the only part of the episode out of place, since it doesn't tie into the episode other then Sinclair using the attacks as an excuse to talk to Kosh. It's more moving pieces into place than movement, but those pieces will be important later.

clhollandwriter: (Default)
"Let me pass on to you the one thing I've learned about this place. No one here is exactly what he appears. Not Mollari, not Delenn, not Sinclair…and not me." - G'Kar
 
This is where Psi Corp start playing a role in things, and we get to see if Ivanova's negative feelings towards them are warranted. Spoiler: they are. The episode also puts some guns in drawers for later use, even if it doesn't seem to do much at first glance.
 
Psi Cops Bester and Kelsey turn up to investigate a rogue telepath Jason Ironheart, who they believe is hiding on the station. They're first seen going through customs, with Bester talking telepathically to a security officer who answers out loud and doesn't appear to notice. Then they arrive at Commander Sinclair's office. He does notice and isn't happy about it - such psychic intrusion is against the rules.
 
Bester is unapologetic. Special circumstances warrant special measures, or at least that's his excuse. He has Sinclair call in the station's resident telepath Talia Winters, who is a former student and lover of Ironheart's, so they can scan her. As they carry out what's obviously a painful and deeply unpleasant procedure on her it becomes clear Bester enjoys the power he has over others.
 
There's some nice characterisation here of Sinclair. He clearly dislikes Bester and what he represents, but he's sympathetic to Talia and tries to shield her, and she's surprised by his compassion. Ivanova features briefly, and in hindsight must have a mind of steel - at this point the audience knows she hates Psi Corps, but not that she herself is an unregistered telepath. While Bester's not permitted to scan the command staff, he'd have no problem picking up their surface thoughts which he's almost certainly monitoring.
 
It's only after the scan that Ironheart makes himself known. He tells Talia he's been subject to Psi Corp experiments to ramp up psychic abilities and as a result he's become a telekinetic. They want to use his powers for assassination. Not only does he not want this, but the powers are growing too fast for him to control. As they speak he has a "mindquake" and tells Talia to run.
 
Sinclair and Talia concoct a plan to get Ironheart off the station safely, although why they thought it could remain a secret is beyond me. Bester sees Sinclair's clearing a route to the docking bay for what it is. There's no attempt at misdirection, although to be fair there isn't a lot of time. After a confrontation in which Kelsey dies, Ironheart escapes and turns into a being of pure energy. He gives Talia a gift before he departs, later revealed to be minor telekinetic powers and an ability to block telepathic scans.
 
While this is going on, Catherine Sakai is hired to conduct a survey of Sigma 957. She's warned off by G'Kar - she needs the permission of the Narn government to proceed - but threatens to go over his head. When she leaves to do the survey he's seen calling the Narn Homeworld for a fighter to go to Sigma 957, apparently making good on his promise that she won't return. However, as he tells her, "no one here is exactly what he appears". When her ship has a brush with an unknown entity and goes into a decaying orbit, it's G'Kar's fighter that rescues her.
 
While this encounter is set up as an unsolved mystery, it's actually doing double duty in introducing elements that will be important later. G'Kar's observations about the nature of the beings at Sigma 957 reveal not only a hidden spiritual side but also set up the idea of the First Ones, and this particular race will be contacted again in season 3. That's some pretty heavy lifting for a B plot.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
"My orders are quite specific. You are to know pain. You are to know fear. And then you are to die at the required hour." - Tu'Pari

This episode deals with some heavy themes - death and religion - but it does it with a light touch, which is a refreshing change after the lack of subtlety in Infection. It also introduces Commander Sinclair's on-again-off-again girlfriend Catherine Sakai, and new aides Na'Toth and Lennier for G'Kar and Delenn.

This episode is a great example of how the show was set up so no one was irreplaceable. G'Kar's aide Ko'Dath has died between episodes in an unfortunately-timed airlock accident, and he's immediately suspicious that Na'Toth arrives not long after he receives a message saying there's an assassin after him. In reality, Ko'Dath actress Mary Woronov had to drop out because she couldn't tolerate the Narn make-up, and her departure is worked into the story in a way that works with the plot. Likewise Blaire Baron, who played Sinclair's girlfriend Carolyn in the pilot, didn't want to return for the main series. During a conversation between Sinclair and Sakai it's revealed that Carolyn left not long after the events of the pilot, and that the off-again-on-again relationship with Sakai predates her - they don't pick up where they left off if either of them is seeing someone else.

The specifics of the contract are that G'Kar should live in fear of the assassin, then be tortured, before being killed 48 hours after watching the message. He does know both fear and pain before being rescued by Na'Toth. G'Kar is proud, and one thing that's slipped in here is his refusal to give the assassin the satisfaction of hearing him scream, a facet of his character that will be important in season four.

While G'Kar's waiting for an assassin, the station is hosting a week-long festival for all the different species to show off their religions. The Centauri contribution is an over-indulgent feast, in which a drunken Ambassador Mollari crawls on the table and kisses the bottom of the goddess of love. It's a tradition dating back to a conflict with the Xon, who once shared their homeworld, and is a celebration of survival. The Xon were presumably a sapient race, as Mollari describes them as a "dominant species" and tells a poor taste joke ("Do you know what the last Xon said just before he died? Aaarrrgghh!"), which positions the Centauri as aggressors even before their subjugation of the Narn. It may even be the reason they're conquerors by nature.

The Minbari perform a rebirth ceremony, in which Sinclair participates to Delenn's obvious delight. Sakai ribs him afterwards that it also doubles as a marriage ceremony, and this throwaway comment takes on a greater significance in hindsight, perhaps being a declaration of intent on Delenn's part. The introduction of Lennier also gives an insight into wider Minbari culture and the larger plot. He won't look at Delenn at first, because her position as a member of the ruling council forbids it. She gently persuades him to look up, then pulls rank and forbids him to speak of her true identity as the Minbari are hiding it from the others. When asked if he understands he replies "No, but understanding is not required, only obedience."

The religions of the other races, including the Narn, are mostly absent apart from a Drazi pilgrim trying to bring a ceremonial blade aboard the station. Since Narn religion features quite heavily in an upcoming episode this is likely a deliberate choice in the writing. Their lack of participation isn't remarked on, so it can be assumed by the viewer that they participate or not - and its certainly easy to imagine they'd refuse to "put on a show" for any audience that included the Centauri.

At the end of the episode, Sinclair introduces the ambassadors to a long line of people from various Earth faiths. It's meant to show of how all religions are equally important, but it feels like a crammed in way of dealing with how you include Earth in the festival without upsetting any viewers. The festival is meant to showcase the dominant religion, and dominant and important are not the same thing. I'm not sure there was a more graceful way out of it, however, and the long line of people to meet suggests faith is still important in the twenty-third century - important in a show that puts it in the centre of the main story.

clhollandwriter: (Default)
"We have to stay here. And there's a simple reason why. Ask ten different scientists about the environment, population control, genetics, and you'll get ten different answers. But there's one thing every scientist on the planet agrees on. Whether it happens in a hundred years or a thousand years or a million years, eventually our Sun will grow cold and go out. When that happens, it won't just take us. It'll take Marilyn Monroe, and Lao-Tzu, and Einstein, and Morobuto, and Buddy Holly, and Aristophanes, and all of this…all of this…was for nothing. Unless we go to the stars." - Jeffrey Sinclair

This one's a monster of the week episode, and while it doesn't do as much heavy lifting as Soul Hunter it still manages to set up some key themes for the show.

First up, there's a reporter on the station. She's been trying to get an interview with Commander Sinclair for Babylon 5's second anniversary, and he's been avoiding her. "He'll grab any chance to take out a ship," she complains to Garibaldi. I'm honestly not sure what she's doing in this episode, as all she does is chase Sinclair for a statement and generally make a nuisance of herself, but I guess they needed a B plot. Since this episode works perfectly well without her it's possible this contributes to the perception of Infection as the weakest episode of the season (according to Wikipedia).

The A plot involves Doctor Franklin, who's now settled in and gets a visit from his old xeno-archaeology teacher. Doctor Hendricks wants help figuring out some artifacts he picked up during an excavation of Ikarra VII. They appear to be some sort of organic machines, which the Vorlons are known (and the Minbari rumoured) to have. Both Hendricks' employer Interplanetary Expeditions and biotech will feature in later episodes. What the viewer knows and Franklin doesn't is that the artifacts have been smuggled onto the station and not been through quarantine. Hendricks' assistant Nelson killed a customs officer to get them in, rather than pay the bribe the man was rather obviously angling for.

This willingness to kill causes the artifacts to bond with Nelson, turning him into a bioweapon designed to protect Ikarra VII. The catch? The weapons were programmed to protect the planet from anyone who wasn't a "pure Ikarran", and once the invasion was over turned on their creators - because no one is pure anything. Ikarra VII is a dead world.

Nelson goes on a rampage, powering up in incremental levels that will destroy Babylon 5 in a matter of hours, and after several failed attempts to stop the weapon with violence Sinclair decides to try to talk it down. In the end he persuades it to look at Nelson's memories of Ikarra VII. Realising it has ultimately failed in its purpose, it shuts down.

After the fight, Garibaldi comes to see Sinclair. He feels the commander is taking too many risks, in a way he's seen before in veterans of the Earth-Minbari war - particularly those who were in the Battle of the Line. In fact he tells Sinclair he's putting himself "on the line" too often, phrasing that can only echo back to what he feels is the source of the problem. And he's right, although not for the reason he thinks. Sinclair is initially offended at the implication he has a death wish, but admits Garibaldi has a point.

Meanwhile, Franklin and Ivanova have an after work drink and muse on the notion of racial purity. Franklin's heard rumours of a pro-Earth movement back on Earth that's committing hate crimes against aliens, and is worried about the future. I don't think it's a coincidence the characters having this conversation are both members of groups with a history of being persecuted, a black man and a Jew. The only thing that stops this being completely heavy-handed (although the rest of the episode isn't subtle by any means) is that it hasn't been stated yet that Ivanova's Jewish. In the middle of the conversation soldiers from Earthforce arrive to confiscate the weapon, showing Franklin is right to be worried.

In the end Sinclair finally meets with the reporter. She asks him if going to space is worth it, or should humans pull back and deal with their own problems on Earth. It's worth it, he tells her, because even if for no other reason one day the Earth will be destroyed and all of humankind's achievements with it. While I understand this is probably Sinclair playing politics, and thinking about all that was lost on Ikarra VII, for me it's a Human-centric response that undermines the rest of the episode.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
"What do you want, you moon-faced assassin of joy?" - Londo Mollari

In episode one the Narn and Centauri were at each other's throats, and in this one Commander Sinclair is tasked with getting them to agree about something - namely to come to a treaty over the Euphrates sector. Not only is he hampered by Ambassadors Mollari and G'Kar's mutual dislike of each other, but also the fact that Mollari is distracted by a love affair with beautiful dancer Adira Tyree.

The episode reveals a lot about Mollari, and about Centauri culture being one obsessed with status. Adira takes joy in Mollari's title, using it even in bed, but when he suggests taking her somewhere public for breakfast she worries at the damage this would do to his reputation. Mollari, for his part, doesn't care about their difference in status. There's something of the mid-life crisis in the way he moons over a younger woman to the detriment of his duties, but it's also our first hint of Londo as a hopeless romantic.

While Londo's shirking his duties, his aide Vir gets to play ambassador. There are some amusing scenes of Vir playing with a handheld videogame console while the negotiators wait for Ambassador Mollari, and of G'Kar and his newly-arrived aide Ko'Dath playing with it together, while Sinclair despairs over the whole thing. Vir himself is so bumbling and good-natured that he seems ill-suited for a career in politics, but his appointment makes sense in a society where influence is everything - Mollari himself has pulled strings to get relatives favourable positions, an important plot point in Midnight on the Firing Line.

What Londo doesn't realise is that Adira's a slave - contracted out by her own government into the service of an alien called Trakis. He wants to use her to gain access to House Mollari's "purple files", the sensitive information held on the other houses that allows them to maintain position and status. Adira reluctantly copies the files, but when the time comes to give them to Trakis she runs instead. Trakis uses devious tricks to find her, bugging Mollari while he and Sincair look for her, then Sinclair uses devious tricks of his own to find out where she is by persuading telepath Talia Winters to take the information from Trakis's surface thoughts. This isn't the first time he's used dirty tricks to solve a problem and it won't be the last, and it makes him much more interesting than his later replacement commander Sheridan who's much more straightforward.

As well as characterisation for Ambassador Mollari, the episode relays character information in the B plot of Garibaldi chasing around the station trying to find out who's using the restricted gold communications channel without authorisation. It turns out it's Ivanova using it to speak to her dying father, a relationship that will feature in a later episode, and it says a lot about her that she hasn't asked Sinclair for permission. Garibaldi figures it out in time to see their final conversation, and later tells her the problem was a computer glitch in such a way as to make sure she knows he found her out and is letting her off - this time. Londo himself gets a bittersweet ending: Adira is freed, but chooses to return home to Centauri space for a time rather than stay with him. While at first glance it doesn't appear this episode does much to tie in to the wider plot, this relationship lays the groundwork for something monumental in season three.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
"It's all so brief, isn't it? Typical human lifespan is almost a hundred years, but it's barely a second compared to what's out there. It wouldn't be so bad if life didn't take so long to figure out. Seems you just start to get it right and then…it's over." - Dr Stephen Franklin

This is the episode that prompted me to look in more detail at what was going on in B5. I'm blindsided by it being the second episode every time, because to me it feels like it should be later, and so I assume it being where it is is a deliberate choice.

The first thing the episode does is introduce Doctor Stephen Franklin, the new chief medical officer. Easier to do in an episode that requires his services, but there are plenty of those that could easily have stood here instead. His services are needed because Sinclair, ever the hands-on commander, has rescued a ship that's dead in space and in danger of crashing into the station. The severely injured occupant is revealed to be a Soul Hunter, and the alien residents start leaving the station in droves.

Where the last episode makes it clear politics has a starring role, this one does it with religion and mysticism. Sinclair and Franklin are sceptical about what being a Soul Hunter actually means, but the aliens take it literally - so much so that Delenn tries to kill him. The Minbari believe in souls and reincarnation, and that Soul Hunters - who capture notable souls at death - diminish them as a people.

This episode also lays a seed, an ever so subtle one, of future events. In answering Franklin the soul hunter tells him to "ask your Commander Minbari friend". While at first this appears to be a scathing assessment of Sinclair as a friend to the Minbari, it can also be taken to mean "ask your friend, Commander Minbari." I don't think this is a coincidence in an episode that deals so heavily with souls and the Minbari perception of them, especially given that later it's revealed that Sinclair does, in fact, have a Minbari soul. It would perhaps have been too on the nose if the episode were later.

Other plot seeds this episode are that the Minbari appear to have plans for Sinclair, but the hints don't come from reliable sources - the obsession-crazed soul hunter ("They're using you!") and a semi-conscious Delenn ("We were right about you"). These sorts of things are scattered throughout, so I think the reason this episode is where it is to start building the underlying mythology and introduce the idea of more nebulous beliefs in a science fiction show.

It's this carefully layered foreshadowing that, I think, made Babylon 5 so successful as a story, and allowed the potentially contradictory elements of science and religion to fit comfortably together. Star Trek: Deep Space 9 did a similar thing (and was set on a space station and around at the same time, to boot) by showcasing the beliefs of the Bajoran people. The two shows approached it differently, of course. DS9 answered the question of whether science or religion was correct by answering "Why not both?" and having the Bajoran's holy Prophets also be aliens with a very different experience of the universe. B5 refused to answer it at all and let the characters and events speak for themselves.

I think this is why the Battlestar Galactica reboot failed so badly when it introduced the"Starbuck's been dead this whole time" plot twist. Although religious belief was shown in both humans and cylons, it wasn't layered in as part of the story. There are multitudes of articles out there about how the writers just threw Starbuck's resurrection in as something cool to do - and it shows. Despite weirdness with mandalas, visions, and Starbuck knowing the song the Final Five cylons heard, Starbuck as angel and saviour of mankind made no narrative sense and the show suffered for it.

In Babylon 5, it's all layered in, and now that I'm paying attention it's amazing to see just how deeply.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
"It was the dawn of the third age of mankind – ten years after the Earth-Minbari War. The Babylon Project was a dream given form. Its goal: to prevent another war by creating a place where humans and aliens could work out their differences peacefully. It's a port of call – home away from home – for diplomats, hustlers, entrepreneurs, and wanderers. Humans and aliens wrapped in two million five hundred thousand tons of spinning metal… all alone in the night. It can be a dangerous place, but it's our last best hope for peace. This is the story of the last of the Babylon stations. The year is 2258. The name of the place is Babylon 5." - Jeffrey Sinclair

We've wandered into a Babylon 5 rewatch at home, which we do every few years. It's the show we most consistently go back to, beating even the delightfully nutty Farscape. We've seen it so many times that this time I found myself watching it differently, paying more attention to the building blocks, foreshadowing, and how it's put together. The show was planned with a five year arc that had to adapt to cast changes, such as the loss of Michael O'Hare (Commander Sinclair) after season 1 and Talia Winters (Andrea Thompson) in season 2, and yet elements ot that arc are seeded in right from the beginning. The sheer amount of craft in writing the thing is astounding, and that got me thinking I should probably write these thoughts down somewhere. Needless to say there will be spoilers, but the show's 25 years old so I make no apologies.

Because this rewatch was a spontaneous thing due to having to resort to *gasp* DVDs for an evening, and needing something that fitted into less than an hour, I haven't actually rewatched the pilot yet. I'll go back to it, but for now here's the start of season one.


S1 E1 - Midnight on the Firing Line

This episode has a lot of heavy lifting to do. Airing for the first time nearly a full year after the pilot it has to re-establish setting, the various alien cultures, reintroduce established characters, and introduce new ones. It does that mostly by treating everything as business as usual. The station isn't new, it's been open a year or so at this point, so everyone's had time to settle in and get used to each other.

Everyone except Lieutenant Commander Ivanova, who became first officer at an unspecified point in the year after the pilot. The change of personnel isn't mentioned, but nodded to in a conversation between Ivanova and Security Chief Garibaldi that reveals she hasn't been around quite long enough to have learned the station commander turns off his link for ten minutes every day and heads off for some peace and quiet. It's a nice note of characterisation that later Garibaldi is able to tell someone looking for Ivanova where she can be found after her shift finishes. This is a man who notices how people behave.

Also new on the station is the resident commercial telepath Talia Winters. She's supposed to present herself to the first officer on arrival, but Ivanova's been avoiding her for weeks. When Talia finally catches up, Ivanova is curt and rude. At first glance this looks like your standard genre everyone-hates-telepaths bigotry, except that no one else reacts to her that way. At the end of the episode Ivanova reveals she doesn't have a problem with Talia but with what she represents - the Psi Corps that destroyed Ivanova's mother on discovering she was an unregistered telepath. It's an understandable reason to be hostile and I get the feeling this was laid out upfront, rather than dragging it out for the sake of tension, to cement early that Ivanova's no bigot.

The episode also puts the politics front and centre (in case you couldn't guess from the opening voiceover). The inciting incident is the Narn invasion of the Centauri colony Ragesh 3, and subsequent forcing of the colonists to publicly declare allegiance to the Narn government. The fact that it's Ambassador Mollari's own nephew who makes the statement is used to discredit his appeal for the other races to intervene. The Narn are clearly being set up as the villains here, but as Commander Sinclair tries to find a peaceful solution it's revealed the two races have a long and bloody history, with the Narn homeworld being subjugated by the Centauri Republic until relatively recently. It also introduces the Babylon 5 Advisory Council and the League of Non-Aligned Worlds, where all the inter-species politics are hashed out in a neutral space.

In the end the situation is diffused with sneaky machinations, some more successful than others. But although the immediate problem is solved it's clear that there's a lot of history between the species, and it's going to make itself known.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
I was reading Lauren Graham's book Talking as Fast as I Can: from Gilmore Girls to Gilmore Girls (and Everything in Between), which didn't have nearly as much Gilmore Girls as the title implies. She talks (a lot) about how much she loved the rebooted show Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, which got me to thinking how much I really didn't and how that's affected my feelings about the main show. I tried to watch it again recently but just found it irritating.

I stumbled across the show on Netflix a couple of years ago, and for a while it was my go-to show when my partner was out. Then one day he caught the end of an episode and was interested enough to watch it with me. I'd binge it on weekends, loving the relationship between Lorelai and Rory, loving to hate the relationship between Lorelai and her parents, and rooting for Rory in her quest to get to Harvard.

When I got to A Year in the Life, I was never excited to get to the next episode and now I think I've figured out why. In the main series Rory was bright and energetic, and full of ambition to get to an Ivy League university. She fought for it, and Lorelai fought for it. In A Year in the Life she'd given up and was drifting, and it was like that whole "living in the pool house" thing except with no light at the end of the tunnel because the audience doesn't know what she wants any more.

Plus, I did not like who Rory turned into between the shows. She apparently didn't learn her lesson about cheating from her fling with now-married ex Dean in the original series, and was having an affair with Logan while both of them have other partners. I could maybe have accepted that had she not also had a boyfriend she kept literally forgetting about. Plus the way she behaved in the job interview. She'd basically turned into an arrogant piece of crap with no regard for other people.

And that ending. While I get that Gilmore Girls was a show about mother-daughter relationships, Rory getting pregnant was never going to be be a happy ending for me. Not on top of the complete failure to do anything with her life. She had all the opportunities in the world, and Lorelai sacrificed so much to give them to her, and she just threw them all away.

There were other issues, like Luke and Lorelai apparently having a completely static relationship for nearly a decade, but Rory's complete personality change was the biggest for me.

There are rumours of a second revival. No word yet on if it's another mini-series or a full show (which seems more likely with a baby on the way). Either way, I'm not actually sure I want to watch it. Stars Hollow no longer has its shine.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
Not a lot to update, since we're not far into the year. I had two publications last year, both in October, and I'm waiting for the publication of another piece of flash that also happens to be the last thing in my inventory that's not published or trunked. I wrote a short thing last week I'm not particularly happy with (certainly not enough to go to the bother of revising and submitting), and something the week before I didn't finish and don't intend to. I'm supposedly working on a story right now but here I am blogging even though blogging is dead, so there you go. 

I have watched a lot of Netflix already this year. We started with Australian mini-series Tidelands, which I loved right up until the last episode when it didn't end so much as stop. This is something DC's Titans is also guilty of, but I read that they moved the final episode of series one to the beginning of series two so at least I know there's more of that. It did mean the first season ended with a particularly bad episode though, with no obvious link to the main plot right until the end, which wasn't particularly interesting. We caught the first episode of Star Trek: Discovery season two yesterday. I'm not sure how I feel about it yet, what with the change of direction, but it was fun and I'm likely to stick around for Stamets, Tilly, and the new engineer anyway. We're also watching season 13 of Supernatural on DVD. That show has some issues (like their treatment of female characters, and some glaring plot holes) but it knows what it is and it's still fun. I was off work two days last week with a bad cold, and started Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries, and have ordered the first of the books it's based on.

Winter is always tough. Once Christmas is out of the way it's just one long slog of cold days and dark nights until spring. The glums hit early this winter too, back in December. I ended up not leaving the house except to go to work for most of the month, because of the crowds, and suffering from a bad bout of depression. The one time I did get out to the shops I ended up abandoning my basket in the store because the queue was ridiculous. I'm mostly feeling better now, trying to keep busy with reading, Netflix, and sorting the house out. It's baby steps, but I'm hoping this year is better than the last, politics notwithstanding.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
I should probably update this since it's a two publication month. 

First up: "The Resurgence of Clowns" over at Daily Science Fiction.
We knew it was happening again when David started juggling.

I wrote the first draft of this in one sitting, just before bed, while listening to scary clown music. It came from a title prompt during a flash fiction contest, and the concept and first line came shortly after.

The second is "Totality", one of my rare science fiction stories which was published at Nature.
Two days ago it had been "we don't negotiate with terrorists", but it was difficult not to negotiate with people who'd stolen the sun.

This one required a bit more research - what would happen when the sun went out? It also came from a title, but not the one I used. It was the gloriously pulpy "The Spacemen who Devoured the Morning" from the Pulp Sci-Fi Title-O-Tron over at Thrilling Tales. That gave me the idea, although it was a far more serious story than the title warranted.


I also found (and spent a couple of hours binge-reading) an amazing creepypasta over on Reddit, called "The Left/Right Game". It 's got me wanting to read more. I also played a fun little text-based game called "You are Jeff Bezos", where you wake up as Jeff Bezos and have to spend all his money. It took a few tries, but I managed to get all three endings.

Finally, I spent this weekend binge-watching The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, which is all kinds of hilarious. I love the changes they've made (Salem doesn't talk, the advice and sarcasm is provided by Sabrina's cousin Ambrose who's under house arrest for trying to blow up the Vatican), although some of the politics is a little on the nose. Perhaps it needs to be, these days, and it does add to the fun.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
At this year's Swanwick Writers' Summer School, crime writer AA Dhand gave some wise (and eminently quotable) advice: "Fail early, fail often, fail forward", and "Change the narrative". The latter accompanied a story about how his father changed the relationship with teenagers who smashed the windows of the family's shop, eventually hiring them as paper boys, simply by sitting down and having a drink with them. Eventually Dhand realised he, too, needed to change the narrative, and start writing the world he knew instead of the one he thought he should be writing - which led to his successful Harry Virdee series.

There are always a number of evening speakers at Swanwick, and they generally have something wise to say, so here's some sage advice from previous years.

- "Let the characters create the story." - Stephen Booth (2017)

- "The point of fiction is to enlarge what's possible." - Sophie Hannah (2017)

- "Know your antagonist as well as your protagonist. They are the hero of their own story." - Imogen Cooper (2017)

- "Don't be cautious, write what you want." - James Runcie (2016)

- "Not all stories will suit your tongue, and not all stories will flow from your pen." - Brendan Nolan (2016)

- "Sometimes it's better to accept a smaller advance rather than a large one that you then struggle to earn out." - Mario Reading (2015)

- "Short stories open small windows into large events." - Zoe Lambert (2013)

- "You should be the audience you writer for." - Curtis Jobling (2013)

- "If you know your voice it will help you stop wasting time writing things that aren't you." - Steve Hartley (2012)

- "Define your own level of success. Don't compare yourself to other writers." - Helen Cross (2011)


It's always interesting to hear what they have to say, and I often find the most enjoyable speakers those who write or work well outside my comfort zone, say in crime fiction or TV drama. It's also reassuring to hear that well established series writers like Stephen Booth are pantsers, that anything is possible. Of course they sometimes contradict each other - Booth was followed the following evening by Sophie Hannah, who tightly plots everything and finds it the best way to keep up with her multiple projects. But that's the nature of writing, nothing works for everyone. However in 2014 I heard the same advice three times, so it must be true: persistence is key; write for yourself; trust your instincts.

clhollandwriter: (Default)
Today is the last day. As always the morning is busy, with the final part of the specialist courses and the last short courses. These were incredibly sensible today, with instruction on Scrivener, grammar, worldbuilding, and Succeeding on Purpose.

I took the latter, which was about setting goals and retraining the brain to look for opportunities instead of saying "I can't". The second half had about a third more people than the first, so word had obviously got around about how funny and engaging the first half was.

Instead of a one-hour course, Thursday always sees the AGM and appointment of next year's committee. The officers were standing unopposed, but there was a vote for the remaining committee positions. The following block on the timetable is labelled Time for You but might as well say Pack Now. After this short break, during which I pack and have a cup of tea, there's the Dregs Party where people unload the last of drinks and snacks they don't want to take home. This is officially held on the lawn but as I type looks in danger of being moved indoors.

Dinner is a three-course affair this evening, to celebrate the seventieth year, and after that is the farewell which includes drawing the raffle and possibly the committee humiliating themselves in the name of entertainment. They never reveal the entertainment in advance but i'm sure some old favorites will make an appearance.

The last night disco is back this year, although my disco buddy isn't here so I'll skip it. Although the programme officially ends around eleven, the bar shuts at twelve and no doubt there will be some who keep the Swanwick spirit going until the early hours.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
I'm posting this a day late as I didn't get a chance yesterday - a Swanwick friend was visiting for one day only so I took the opportunity to spend time with her instead.

Tuesday's speaker Simon nelson was excellent. He went over five-act structure, and how turning points happen at the mid-point of the story. We also looked at the beginnings of TV shows Happy Valley and The 4 O'clock Club to illustrate pacy, grabby openings. I took more notes than for any other evening speaker, more than for some courses!

Wednesday saw the return of the regular run of courses, with our crime investigation turning from preservation of the scene and forensics, to the actual investigation. We took a closer look at the crime scene in the corner, and ran a mock press conference.

The short courses included a look at "wild words", song writing, and editing, and I took the final parts of the Writing as a Business course, which was unusually running as two short courses instead of as a specialist course. We looked at project and time management, something I desperately need to do better at.

In the usual one hour course slot we had a birthday celebration for the school, with a "school photo" (the first since 1956) and birthday cake. 

The evening speaker was Sophie Snell, storyteller, singer, and folkorist. She also has a psychological thriller out in November, based on fairy tales. Something else to add to my wishlist!

I stayed up late in the bar for the first time this week, chatting to my friend. Thursday is the final day, featuring the last of the four part courses, and a mystery instead of a speaker since they never reveal what's going into the farewell.
clhollandwriter: (Default)
I skipped the speakers last night in favour of an early night, although those who went say it was excellent. Tuesday is generally a lighter day, although there was a change to the usual format this year as most of the one hour sessions have been moved to Tuesday slots to allow for celebratory events (Swanwick at 70 and a birthday party) during the 4pm slots on Monday and Wednesday.

First up this morning were Acting for Writers, Dear Della (a session with writing agony aunt Della Galton), Niche Publishing, Writing for the Under Eights, and the course I took, Promoting Your Work with resident crime writer Val Penny. While I knew about Twitter and Facebook pages, I came away with a list of Facebook groups to check out, and a list of dos and don'ts which included DO write more, and DO be proud of your work, two things I always struggle with.

The second session offered courses on Erotica, Mind Mapping, being a Writer in Residence, Reviewing, and an excellent course on New Fairy Tales. Tutor Elizabeth Hopkinson is an enthusiast and I left not only with websites and Facebook groups to check out, but also a huge list of books to add to my wishlist.

I went for a nap at this point as I was feeling unwell, but emerged for the tea dance (although to watch, not participate).

This evening's speaker is Simon Nelson of the BBC's Writersroom, to speak about TV drama. I may go if I feel up to it.

June 2023

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
1112131415 1617
18192021222324
252627282930 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 17th, 2025 01:14 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios